Shmoop eavesdrops on your favorite critic's online convos.
Toril Moi
Hey, Julia, just wanted to do a shout-out. It's been a while. Is it something I said? Didn't say? Was it that I used language or should not have used language? Something else altogether?
Look, I know this is Facebook so we're supposed to keep things lite, but when it comes to the child-mother bond, I'm not down with the chuckles.
Toril Moi
But aren't we, by virtue of using the language of the Father right now, implicating ourselves in the very system you condemn? Aren't we bowing to social constraints?
Are you still beating that drum, Julia? For someone who finds collective identity so odious, you seem all too ready to make women intellectuals out to be one mutually thinking and feeling entity.
Sometimes I feel that it is the plight of the female intellectual to be isolated. It's lonely work. Look, I just find that— in the words of the demi-god James Brown: "This is a man's world, this is a man's world…"
Luce Irigaray
You are forgetting the next line: "But it wouldn't be nothing, nothing without a woman or a girl."
No, just been super busy theorizing the pre-Oedipal, signifying language, and language's infinite possibilities.