ShmoopTube

Where Monty Python meets your 10th grade teacher.

Search Thousands of Shmoop Videos

How Does Thoreau Feel about Commerce? 41 Views


Share It!


Description:

How does Thoreau feel about commerce? He writes, "We don't ride upon the railroad; it rides upon us." He wants and end to the war fighting for the almighty buck.


Transcript

00:02

Okay here's Question The stance taken by the road in

00:04

the last paragraph can best be described as what All

00:06

right well let's go back here You've got to get

00:08

to the last paragraph is like a dream confederacy made

00:10

up of penn state senate itself in all its so

00:11

called internal movement without leaving its mark Simplicity of like

00:13

that So let's see where are we Well the correct

00:18

answer here Yeah It's c he's a critic of commerce

00:21

is an end goal So the last paragraph sees throw

00:24

railing hop pun intended there against commerce He suggests that

00:28

it hurts regular people going so far as to say

00:31

that the railroad rides up on us He criticizes people

00:35

who insist the nation must be able to export ice

00:38

use a telegraph and ride on trains regardless of whether

00:41

they themselves ever get to do any of those things

00:44

like the nation can do it But the individual What

00:46

about him or her Well his main problem is that

00:49

this thirst for growth goes unexamined like the life not

00:53

worth living He's unsure if rapid growth contributes to the

00:57

health and well being of the country And well he

00:59

just like humanity to reconsider the centrality of commerce in

01:03

life you have fighting for the almighty buck All right

01:06

Well he's a definite curmudgeon But not all grumpy old

01:10

men are traditional or conservative Eso es get rid of

01:13

that In fact the row is quite a radical even

01:15

though some of his ideas advocate a return to a

01:18

simpler time Small scale family farming seems to fit in

01:22

with his police But now he doesn't mention it in

01:24

the passage here so we can just make it up

01:26

and throw it in there So get rid of b

01:28

And finally he doesn't believe that the germans or anyone

01:31

else are out to get us he's using germany as

01:33

a symbol or rather a metaphor for over complication Alright

01:38

so more on the simplify simplify scale So just keep 00:01:41.452 --> [endTime] doing it

Related Videos

SAT Reading 1.1 Long Passages
380 Views

SAT Reading: Long Passages Drill 1, Problem 1

SAT Reading: Classifying the Relationship Between Two Passages
179 Views

How was the Beanie Baby era parallel to the Tulip Bubble? Similar events, only the TulipMania almost bankrupted Holland. Bean Babies only bankrupte...

SAT Reading: Citing Evidence to Identify a Theme in Walden
35 Views

Contemplating one's life is key to fulfilled happiness. Thoreau's theme revolves around the simple life well lived. He clearly never tried virtual...

SAT Reading: Why Does Thoreau Use the Phrase "Mechanical Aids" in this Passage?
58 Views

Thoreau was all about simplicity; anything that took away from his vision was the enemy. Mechanical aids were one of them. Guess he had to train a...

What Does the Author Mean by "Front" in this Context?
25 Views

Thoreau uses "front" to mean "face". He wants to face The Facts of Life without shying away from our natural tendencies, roots, and the simply way...