- They have an awkward conversation in which Cath agrees to try again.
- He puts her laptop in her lap and asks her to read him some fanfiction; he remembers exactly where they left off six weeks ago.
- There's a long Simon Snow interlude, then Cath asks about Reagan. How long did they date? Did he love her?
- He says three years, and yes.
- However, she cheated, and they got to college and realized there were more people to date than the eleven in their high school class.
- Cath details all the stuff they don't have in common, and Levi says none of that stuff matters.
- She tells him she doesn't trust anyone, and he says that's crazy.
- Exactly, says Cath—she's crazy, just like her dad.
- He says it doesn't matter if she's crazy, and asks her out for the following night. She says yes, because she may be crazy, but she's not stupid.
- Cath stays up late writing fanfiction. She asks Reagan if it's okay if she goes out with Levi.
- Reagan says yes, but it's weird, and Cath lucked out getting with Levi, because Levi usually goes for girls who are giant pains.