Character Analysis
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6af48/6af4893e395a8029ba07ab73df097244c17e5652" alt=""
(Click the character infographic to download.)
Professor Dumbledore is certainly a force for good. Still, there is evidence that he knows more about what is happening at Hogwarts than he is telling. After Colin Creevey is found Petrified outside the Hospital Wing, Professor Dumbledore comments, "The question is not who […] The question is, how…" (10.178). Why doesn't Professor Dumbledore just tell everyone – or even just Professor McGonagall – who the culprit is, if he knows?
This moment with Professor Dumbledore in Book 2 foreshadows the widening rift that's going to come between him and Harry over precisely this issue: why can he never just explain what's happening? For now, though, Harry is willing to put all of his trust in Professor Dumbledore without fully knowing why. Harry is still a child and not yet ready to be a leader, so he needs a figure of kindly authority to reassure him. It's not until Book 5 that he grows ready to move away from Professor Dumbledore's strong influence over him. It's not until Book 5, as well, that we begin to see Professor Dumbledore as a character with faults and flaws, instead of the benevolent, all-knowing power he appears to be in Chamber of Secrets.