If Only Chapter 43 Summary

Secrets

  • Another bombshell from the journal: Sophie's dad wasn't her biological dad. Her parents used a sperm donor.
  • Sophie found out because she overheard her parents talking about it—she was already an adult and pregnant with Corinna at the time.
  • Corinna wonders if Sophie would have ever told her, and why she didn't think it was important to do so before she died.
  • She remembers the morning her dad came to her room and told her Sophie had passed away in the night. She feels guilty that she was afraid to see Sophie's body before the undertaker came, and wishes she had said goodbye.